• Melanie Wilson

When to Cross The “Let Them Fail To Succeed” Line and Get Involved?

When this article first appeared on Grown and Flown in November 2019 I shared it and it got a ton of response. A lot of people have their own tales to share about times they felt is was necessary to intervene--oh rather, help out, their adult children. Here's hoping their learning and growth continues, either because of or in spite of us!

My daughter is no baby, but at 26 years old she is still having some experiences for the first time.

When she turned 26 a few months ago, she was required by law to go off our health, dental, and vision plans and onto her own. Although she moved across the country a few years back, her visits home came often enough so that she was able to keep many of her childhood healthcare providers, including the family dentist.

Identifying new local providers is toward the top of her “I need to adult now list,” but she has had no need for any, until a few nights ago when severe dental pain awoke her.

She called me sobbing the next day, fully aware of my in-depth familiarity with the debilitating pain of dental woes.

It sounded like she might need a root canal. Her insurance company was able to provide her with a dentist that was not too far from her office, and she got an appointment for that afternoon.

She texted me from the chair.

“He said I need six root canals,” she wrote.

WHAT? Is that even a thing?

Through the next five minutes or so of texting back and forth, I realized my daughter had no clue. Was this my fault? I prepared her well enough to keep away from the “bad man at at the mall” but did I not teach her that it was possible that even professionals could try to bilk her?

To make sure I was not overreacting, I quickly googled “multiple root canals” and even “I need six root canals.” I wasn’t overreacting.

Looking back over the texts I sent her, my message was clear.


“Stop him”

“Do not proceed until our dentist reviews the x-rays”

Her answer: “The doctor is about to come back in.”

Clearly, she was not comfortable having to be put into a “defy authority” situation. This was the little girl who cried when her Brownie leader once thought she was disrupting the group when it was actually the child next to her. She is such a people pleaser, and now she had to stand up to the doctor and tell him that she was not trusting his recommendation.

Still texting, she wrote, “The insurance person is coming to talk to me. What do I say.”

More Mommy guilt. How could my child be so ill-prepared?

It was mid-afternoon on a Friday in the east, and our dentist’s office was closed. I left messages on the office phone, sent an email through the web site, and left a message on the emergency number while she was still in the chair. He called back within moments.

Knowing her history, he agreed that the diagnosis was ludicrous.

His words were “Absurd. Run out of here. Unethical. She has nothing remotely going on. I’d be shocked if she needed one.”

She did leave the office without getting any work done. The dentist told her she was crazy. He made some comment about “Mom on the phone.”

Yeah, well, so what?

I know at some point--and in some situations--she needs to learn life’s hard lessons on her own. But, what is that point?

Our instinct as parents is to protect our children. Just because my daughter is an adult does not weaken that need I have to protect her.

Common sense--and lots of good articles--tell us that if we don’t let them fail they won’t be prepared for life. But isn’t thwarting off unnecessary procedures in a different league than letting a child suffer through school-provided cheese and crackers because they forgot their lunch, or getting a bad mark because they left their clarinet at a friend’s house?

I questioned my involvement, and turned to a parenting authority to weigh in.

Summit, NJ Parenting Coach Lisa DiSciullo, of Parenting Matters, said, “With older children, our role shifts from being a parent manager to a parent consultant. We can be there to offer advice, when asked, and to coach them through handling their own problems.”

DiSciullo said, “In this case, you have much more life experience and you gave her your opinion when she asked. The issue comes when we take problems over for our kids or get overly directive in how they have to handle it. If, when she called you, you said: give me your insurance company information; I’ll find a dentist for you; I’ll make an appointment for you; and conference me in when it’s time to make any decisions on work to be done and I’ll talk to him, you would be taking over and enabling her to be more dependent on you.”

We do our best to prepare our kids for the grown-up situations they will face--until an acute situation arises that requires an immediate decision. We offer our input to ensure that they don’t hurt themselves--physically or financially.

But, where should we draw the line? Should the let-them-learn-and-grow-from-their-failure mentality still apply if their decisions can have less physical consequences than unnecessary dental/medical procedures?

What about the car mechanic who tells our kids that they need a new carburateur?

Or the exterminator who tells them there is a termite problem that can’t be seen?

A young adult in a new city might get tripped up by some of this, particularly if she has not developed a network of trusted professionals. Yelp can only go so far. Our children don’t have a lifetime of experience to know when something seems off.

I remember a time when I was in grad school and I was buying my first used car. I phoned my dad with questions and the salesman bullied me into thinking I was immature for reaching out to him. I was embarrassed. Conjuring up this moment provided me with the empathy I needed to help my daughter leave that dentist’s office.

DiSciullo said, “Rarely do decisions have to be made in the moment, and what others think or imply is their behavior and we can choose to respond however we like.”

She said, “Parents need to step in when there’s a question of health and safety, like a toddler climbing a wobbly barstool, a middle schooler playing with firecrackers unsupervised, or a young adult who can’t function because of excessive drinking.”

My daughter’s problem is yet to be resolved. A second dentist referred her to an endodontist, and she is popping Motrin until she sees him.

DiSciullo suggests I use this experience as a jumping off point for more discussion.

“There’s also some learning in having the conversation about what her opinion was when she called you, what information she had, how she processed that, and what she would have decided had you not been available,” she said.

This makes me wonder about other life lessons I may have missed, and how to discover the correct balance between looking out for our kids and letting them fail so that they can learn.

I think our kids will be more likely to succeed if they know that while they should figure out for themselves if they can eat chicken after the expiration date, or if they should take a personal day for a bad case of PMS, it’s okay to come to us for our input in making critical decisions. We love them. We support them. We show them the skills we use to make good choices, and then we guide them to be able to make them for themselves. At least someday.



T: (908) 337-5402

  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn Social Icon
  • Twitter Clean